A Rant on my Family's Dysfunction
I've got to get this off my chest, and since I can't say this to the person to whom it needs to be said to, I'm posting it here.
Not the most effective way of communicating – I realize this – but isn't it dysfunction that makes the world go 'round?
Two of my aunts recently told my mother that I am "snooty" and "very sure of myself" and my mother told me this on a long car ride. I wasn't really sure what to say at the time, or why my mother was telling me this.
Now that I've had some time to think about it, I'm angry. I can't tell my mother everything that I want to say for a variety of reasons, so I'm going to say it here.
Here's my rant, for your enjoyment:
First of all, since when is "being sure of yourself" a BAD trait to have?
Isn't it a valuable quality – especially for women? I would rather be sure of
myself and be wrong sometimes than DOUBT myself and then be right later.
And if we're talking about personality flaws here, isn't it better to be "sure of"
yourself, as opposed to being rude, gossipy, mean, or inconsiderate?
Would you ever say to Aunt T., "I think your daughter's a little too insecure
and people don't like that."
Or would you say to Aunt F., "Your son's too quiet and comes across as
stand-offish and people don't like that."
No - you would never say these things. Why? Because they're rude comments
and you are not a rude person. I would never say these things either because
I'm not rude either. (My mom taught me to be nice to people.)
It would be one thing if I said or did something that offended Aunt F. It would
be one thing if Aunt T. felt that in my "sureness" of myself, I was putting her
daughter C. down and hurt someone's feelings. In those cases, I can totally
see my aunts talking to you about it and then you turning around and telling
me about it.
But I don't understand how they think that it's perfectly okay to just voice
their complaints about my personality to you. And I don't understand WHY
they would do that.
I have opinions about everyone in this family: aunts, uncles, and cousins. Not
all of those opinions are wonderful, positive things. Would I ever go around
and TELL those people or their parents what I REALLY think about them?
No, I wouldn't. There's no need to, and there's no benefit in doing that. The
only thing you really accomplish by doing something like that is hurting
people's feelings. And, for what? For no good reason.
So somehow it's okay for my aunts to tell you that they think I'm snooty and
too sure of myself. And then you turn around and tell me these things.
If anyone said anything critical of you or my brother to me, my first reaction
would be to defend you, whether or not I agreed with the critical comment.
Secondly, I would never turn around and TELL you or my brother what this
person said because I know that it would hurt your feelings and I wouldn't
want to do that. Especially not for comments that are so unnecessary.
Let's even give them the benefit of the doubt and say that these comments
were taken out of context. Let's assume that you were having a conversation
with them where everyone was complaining about everyone else's kids, and
that's just what they happened to say when you got around to talking about me.
Assuming that was the case, in telling me what Aunt F. and Aunt T. REALLY
think about me, what did you hope to accomplish? What POINT were you
trying to make to me?
Do you want me to just be aware of how they feel about me?
Do you want me to change my behavior to better suit them?
Do you want to hurt my feelings?
I don't understand.
Because now, I'll either have to come to terms with the fact that that's just
how they feel and get on with my life, OR when I'm around them I'll have to
review in my head what I want to say before I say it, so I don't seem snooty
or too sure of myself.
Either way, now that I know what they think, I can't really look at them the
same way.